Ever since I posted my Everlane jeans try on review post last year, Everlane jeans continue to be one of my most popular sellers. And since I know that you love them so much, I couldn’t wait to update y’all with a little Fall Everlane try on! I’m sharing a new style of jeans and plenty of fall-ready tops and sweaters! If you are specifically interested in Everlane denim, head over to my big Everlane denim review post! 

Fall Everlane Try on

Since I’m pretty much a straight leg denim gal now, I was super-excited to see that Everlane released a new style of straight leg jeans! I also found a cotton cardigan sweater that I’m obsessed with, the perfect fall jacket, and several layering tops! I hope y’all love my Fall Everlane finds as much as I do!

My Sizing

For reference, I’m 5’7 1/2″ with a short torso and very long legs! I typically wear a 28/29 in jeans or a size 8. My bra size is a 36C, and I typically wear a size medium (or 8) top. These sizes are what I consider my “true size.”

If you ever have any question about what size I’m wearing, check the links below each image! I list any recommendations I have for sizing up or down for quick reference. (TTS= true to size!) For full details, I’ll be chatting all about quality, style, and fit in the paragraphs above each photo. Let’s go!

Cotton Button-Front Cardigan + High Rise Straight Leg Jeans

We’re starting off strong with one of my favorite finds of the try-on: this 100% cotton button-front cardigan! Everlane gifted me this sweater a few weeks back, and I’ve been wearing it a ton! The quality is amazing. It’s a thicker sweater with zero itch. It has a beautiful chunky weave to it with an oversized fit. The length is slightly cropped, making it a great option to tuck into jeans! You can also wear it tucked into high waisted skirts or pants! Another easy way to wear it is open layered over a cami or tee. It comes in three other colors! Fit is TTS.

And here are the new pair of Everlane straight leg jeans! Unlike most of their straight leg jeans, these have 2% elastane, giving them the tiniest bit of stretch! The rise is high, hitting a little above my belly button. In general, Everlane denim tends to fit me a little more snug at the waist. So if you have a similar figure to mine (or are in-between sizes), you may want to size up! These also come in a dark rinse and washed black denim. 

Sweater (TTS) | Jeans (TTS, size up if in between) | Mules (size up 1/2) 

Puff Sleeve Blouse + High Rise Straight Leg Jeans 

I’ve been on the hunt for a puff sleeve blouse, so I was excited to try this one from Everlane. I like that the puff sleeve is dropped, keeping the shoulder area slimmer. It also has a split neck and a higher neckline. In fact, the neckline felt like it was starting to come up on my neck, which I didn’t love. The fabric is also super-lightweight and somewhat sheer. It is probably better suited for warm weather! I’m in an 8. 

Top (TTS) | Jeans (TTS, size up if in between) | Mules (size up 1/2) 

Waffle Henley Shirt 

Shirts like these are one of my favs for fall and winter! They make great layering pieces! And this one is 100% organic cotton. I adore the waffle texture, and the quarter henley gives me borrowed-from-the-boys menswear vibes. It comes in five colors. I ordered two of them since I wasn’t sure which one I’d prefer in person. Honestly I love them both! Which one would y’all keep?!

Want to layer up? Just add any jacket, sweater or vest! I quickly grabbed my fleece vest to show y’all one way that I’d wear it! So cute and cozy, no?!

Henley (TTS) | Vest (TTS) | Jeans (TTS, size up if in between) | Mules (size up 1/2) 

Cotton Long Sleeve Tee 

My first-ever purchase from Everlane was a tee, and if you haven’t tried them before, they are good. I ordered two styles. The first up is their Air cotton tee. The name is so fitting! It’s a super lightweight 100% cotton tee with the perfect drapey relaxed fit! Tees like this are an absolute staple for the cooler months! It comes in four colors and fits TTS.

Tee (TTS) | Jeans (TTS, size up if in between) | Mules (size up 1/2) 

Boyfriend-style Long Sleeve Tee 

The other style of tee I was excited to try is the boxy pocket tee. It’s made of 100% organic cotton and has a slightly more substantial fabric feel compared to the air tee. The cut is a bit boxy and cropped. The fit is relaxed but I was honestly hoping for even more of an oversized fit. I would prefer sizing up to a large for a true boyfriend fit! If you like this fit, stay TTS. It comes in five colors.

Tee (TTS or size up) | Jeans (TTS, size up if in between) | Mules (size up 1/2) 

Chore Jacket  

Y’all, I love this jacket. LOVE IT. Have you gotten on board with the shacket trend, yet? Because this is the perfect shirt-like jacket! It’s made of 100% cotton and has a sturdy but soft canvas feel! The fit is slim but spacious enough to layer with sweaters. It comes in four colors, but of course I was drawn to the copper. I’m just buying all of the orange tones these days! I’m in the medium. 

Jacket (TTS) | Tee (TTS or size up) | Jeans (TTS, size up if in between) | Mules (size up 1/2) 

Cashmere Henley Sweater 

Another absolute fav!! This cashmere henley, which was gifted to me by Everlane, is gorgeous in person! I love that it has an updated, on-trend vibe with the henley top and slightly ballooned sleeves. But it still looks classic enough to be a wardrobe staple. It’s made of 100% grade-A cashmere and comes in four colors. 

Sweater (TTS) | Jeans (TTS, size up if in between) | Mules (size up 1/2)  

Teddy Liner Jacket 

This jacket is made of 100% recycled bottles. How cool is that?! Unfortunately sizing is pretty limited, but there are a few sizes available in the black version! I’m in a medium but could easily size down to a small. It runs oversized and a little boxy. The material is so soft. It’s lightweight but simultaneously feels so warm! It makes a great outer layer for those of you living in warmer climates. For colder temps, it’s the perfect layering piece to go under heavier coats!

Jacket (runs large) | Henley (TTS) | Jeans (size down) | Sneakers (TTS) 

If you haven’t checked it out already, be sure to also read my Everlane jeans review!